What should I get for my boyfriend at Valentine's?
This question is the most popular question we've received, much more popular that the inverse:  What do I get my girlfriend for Valentine's?
So let me assure you that you should plan on doing something (or getting something) for your boyfriend at Valentine's Day.  But the watchwords are: Keep it cute or funny, keep it simple, and personalize it. 
Cute Valentine's Gift
Cute?  A teddy bear or stuffed animal?  I really don't think so, though something small and related to who he is is acceptable:  A stuffed animal that represents a nickname, the name of a team that he plays for, or a team that he roots for.
A bone or chew toy for his dog?  Catnip for his cat?  (Just a cute add-on gift there.)
A cute or funny not-too-mushy card is probably best.  It would be even better if you could make a cute card.  Just cut out a heart shape out of an old painting or even gift wrap and write something cute and simple on it.
A small novelty gift that is perfect for him would also be a good choice.  One of my boyfriend's favorite gifts was a silly little punching bag (just a few inches high) that sang out expletives and insults when somebody punched at it.  He thought it was hilarious.  
Simple Valentine's Day Gift
Simple?  Cookies, candy, a home-cooked meal, a bottle of wine (if you are old enough)is simple.  Maybe music, a favorite movie, or even a book?  Try baking cupcakes or cookies or a whole cake for him! 
A Personal Valentine's Day Gift
Personalize it?  Something he's mentioned that he would really like.. if it is in your budget.  I bought my boyfriend a police scanner radio one Valentine's Day.  He had mentioned it and obviously wanted it but he didn't want to buy it for himself.  
I once bought him a bottle of "Red Truck" wine.  The label was very cute, and he had just finished a project at work that involved red trucks.  
And a handmade card.. or some handmade decorations:  
Make a "display" in a corner of your (or his) home:  Clean off a small table, put a fabric covering or tablecloth over it, place the gift and the unopened card on the table, perhaps even a small vase of flowers, and sprinkle about small paper hearts, perhaps some red lights... and the candies or cookies.  I also save last year's Valentine's Day cards, and I tape them up behind the display.  (Of course, you wouldn't do that if you were with somebody else last Valentine's Day.. that would be tacky!)   
(I'm writing a separate blog entry about Valentine's Day displays, so more later on that!)  
Just for the record, here is a picture of that bottle of red truck wine... The quality is poor as the pic was taken with a cell phone: 
To summarize: 
One or two small gifts, something cute or something he has specifically mentioned that he wants, something to eat, and remember the presentation!  Always add a personal touch to something!  He'll think you are great and he won't feel overwhelmed.
Keep it simple!